The Jewish Museum Takes on Racism in Israel, Then Backs Away

The Jewish Museum, otherwise known as “that place you take Grandma when she visits,” now has the most cutting-edge artistic social commentary in the Jewish world.

By an incredibly grand stroke of luck, Israel’s whole violence-against-African-refugees thing blew up right in the middle of their  exhibit by Kehinde Wiley, composed exclusively of portraits of men of color in Israel.

The exhibit was already a bold move for the Jewish Museum, given that Wiley’s repertoire is centered around portraits of black men, with motifs that blend and riff on the European Masters, West African textiles, Islamic motifs and Haruki Murakami. (Serious question: Did the Jewish Museum pick Wiley because they mistook his first name for Yiddish? “Such nachas from the kehinde! Here, let me show you pictures of my kehinde-leh.”)

Wiley is known for featuring men he meets on the street, initially in Harlem and now from locations spanning several continents (Nigeria, Brazil, China.) Israel is included among the countries selected for the collection titled “The World Stage” because, according to the Museum, the men in the series “express a modern sensibility that supersedes religious and ethnic affiliations.” Really? The YouTube shirt supercedes the fact that its wearer can’t serve in the military and get a good job?

According to the artist, Wiley included Israel in his world tour because he “wanted to mine where the world is at right now and chart the movement of black and brown men around the world.” Well, Kehinde, apparently the movement of black and brown men to and within Israel is pretty brutal: 52% of Israelis polled call African migrants “a cancer,”  politicians attempt to classify them as “economic migrants” and the asylum system apparently exists merely to formalize mass deportations and repatriations of the black men fleeing certain death.

The video of the artist on the exhibit homepage shows him celebrating the diversity of Israeli society, relishing the opportunity to create powerful representations of Arab, Ethiopian, and Sephardi men. Yet we are very far from the moment when we can celebrate Israel’s diversity, when 99.9% of African asylum seekers are turned away and those who remain are subject to relentless poverty and violence.

Now might be an auspicious time for the Jewish Museum to capitalize on its newfound, perhaps unprecedented, relevance. They could provide new commentary from the artist or opportunities for discussion about the relationship between the exhibit’s subjects and the humiliating discrimination that many black men have been subjected to at the hands of the Israeli public.

Wiley attempts to challenge the hierarchy of representation in a world determined to dehumanize men of color; there can be no more poignant example of the forces he is up against than the riots and soundbites of the past several weeks.

Alas, when asked whether the Museum would consider seizing the moment through expanded commentary or programming, their response was a firm disavowal: “We have done nothing of the sort, and it’s not something we have even considered.” Even Grandma might be disappointed by this missed opportunity.

What do you think?

About The Author

Amy Schiller

Amy Schiller writes about politics, feminism, philanthropy and pop culture. Her work has appeared in The Nation, Salon, Alternet, Heeb, and other publications. She previously worked for five years as a political organizer and non-profit fundraising consultant. You can read more at amybessschiller.com and follow her at @justaschill.

4 Responses

  1. Marc

    If you are black and visit Israel you will learn from the first moment negativity in treatment. Get use to see street hate violence and government negative comments against others than Jews.
    But, you’re not going to see this news in the main media (censorship). Israelis are the most racist people I ever met. It’s a nightmare.

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/jun/04/israel-migrant-hate

    Reply
  2. saddened

    I think it’s the zealot religions of all types that are very prejudice..yes, they all are. I just don’t want it to go down that it’s more than Israel,, Just please don’t think this has anything to do with Jews..we definitely have no problem..It’s all religious folks. Look at our government. Michelle Buttman and the other creep, want only “Christians” in office; right here, in the USA! And those murderers and thieves are only “Christian” on their birth certificates. It’s everywhere and it’s rampant,, Let them share a blame ok!! sorry, peace, and good luck

    Reply
  3. saddened

    Marc. Oops, you forgot the part about the black “illegals” being rapists and thieves and don’t believe we should inhabit the country.. oops oops This is why Peace

    Reply
  4. citytsar

    Thousands of illegal Sudanese immigrants raping women and stealing doesn’t exactly inspire unity and love.

    Reply

Leave a Reply