Will This Knight Be Different From All Other Knights?

As assorted readers are doubtlessly aware, DC Comics, the venerable Jewish comic book company (is that redundant?) is in the process of relaunching its universe. Now, Jewdar, traditionalist that we are about such things, is not necessarily thrillsville with the notion of tinkering with the classics. But as long as they are going to do it anyway, there is something they might want to consider.

Although there are those who babble on about how “Jewish” this or that comic book character is a Member of the Tribe (“Superman believes in justice, that’s a Jewish value!”), Jewdar likes his Jewish characters to be a little more explicit (there’s a reason we’re not called “Mediterraneandar.”) Traditionally, Jewish characters in comics were one of three kinds:
1. Non-existent: We could give DC a little slack, since Metropolis, Gotham City, etc. aren’t real. But the Marvel Universe is set mostly in NYC. Simple statistics suggest that a random sampling of white New Yorkers should be pretty Jewlicious. Kitty Pryde doesn’t cut it (and she’s from Chicago, to boot).
2. An irrelevant afterthought: The Jewish characters are either B-listers, or, when a major figure, it’s completely unmentioned, until they have the issue where it is (like the Thing, who used to visit his old neighborhood on Yancy Street all the time, suddenly having an emotional reawakening of his Jewish identity forty years after the comic started running).
3. Absurdly ghettoized caricatures: Saintly rabbis, earnest Israelis (anyone remember Sabra?) and heroes who are living embodiments of King David, the Maccabees, the Second Avenue Deli, etc. etc.

So while we’re not Thrillsville about eh DC reboot, we do think this is a great opportunity to throw a little bit of the Tribe into the mix. Now, Superman is from another planet, Wonder Woman is a creation of the Greek gods, and that leaves of the Big Three just one, Batman, whose relaunch is happening today.

And really, it’s a pretty logical choice. Back in the 1930’s, it made some sense for Bruce Wayne, scion of one of Gotham’s finest families, to be a WASP. But look around NYC and see whose names are on the hospital, university and theater buildings. Don’t get us wrong…Batman has to be named Bruce Wayne. But who’s to say he wasn’t named after his great-grandfather, Baruch Wien?

What do you think?

About The Author


The Tel Aviv-born, Milwaukee-bred Jewdar has a bachelors' from the University of Wisconsin, a Masters from NYU, and an Honorable Discharge from the US Army, where he spent two years as an infantryman in the 101st Airborne Division. He's the co-author of "The Big Book of Jewish Conspiracies", the Humor Editor of Heeb Magazine, and a watcher of TV. Smarter than most funny people, funnier than most smart people, he lives on the Lower East Side with his wife and two sons.

7 Responses

  1. David

    Personally the most obvious to be jewish would probably be spider-man. He did DATE Kitty Pryde in the Ultimates version but never got a chance to convert.

  2. Herb Perone

    Great book — “Up, Up and Oy Vey!” — written by an orthodox rabbi, no less — traces the Jewish roots of a number of comic book characters, many of whom were created and drawn by Jewish illustrators who couldn’t get work in regular publishing houses back in the 30s and 40s. Superman is a science fiction Moses — put in a spaceship instead of a basket and sent into the unknown by his loving parents so he would not be destroyed, lived among aliens and had to conceal his true origins and identity, etc etc. The Thing is a golem. Check out the book – and there are others like it — to connect with our fictional Hebrew brethren.

  3. jewdar

    Forget about Kitty Pryde–Peter Parker lives in Forest Hills, and his parents were accused of being communist spies. But they were innocent, which suggests that they weren’t Jews.

  4. JDE

    “like the Thing, who used to visit his old neighborhood on Yancy Street all the time, suddenly having an emotional reawakening of his Jewish identity forty years after the comic started running”

    The gamma radiation screwed with his memory.

  5. jewdar

    Pardon my super geekiness, but the Hulk was gamma radiation, the Thing was cosmic rays.

  6. Camber

    Kitty Pryde cuts it. When I was a kid reading X-Men, miles from any sizeable Jewish community, Kitty Pryde was one of my few clues that there were a ton more Jews out there, somewhere, and some of them were X-Men and kicked ass.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This will close in 0 seconds